Does it Matter if You Raise Heritage Chicken Breeds or Hybrids?

Learn What is a Heritage Chicken and What is a Hybrid Chicken


White Rock hen

Heritage chicken breeds are vital to the future of all breeds of chickens. What are heritage chicken breeds? You may be asking this question if you start looking at different breeds of chickens to start a backyard flock. The distinction is important. According to The Livestock Conservancy, a heritage chicken is hatched from a heritage egg sired by an American Poultry Association Standard breed established prior to the mid-20th century. It is slow growing and naturally mated with a long productive outdoor life. All of our hybrid chicken breeds are the result of mating between heritage chicken breeds.

How do Heritage Chicken Breeds Make a Hybrid Chicken?

So, what are the advantages of a hybrid chicken? A hybrid chicken breed has the possibility of possessing the best qualities of all the heritage breeds in its genetic makeup. Do you want a consistently high production egg layer for an egg business? The crosses between some of the traditional heritage egg laying breeds have resulted in hybrid breeds that come into lay early. In addition, they lay nearly every day and reliably produce large delicious eggs.


The sex-linked hybrids are popular choices for egg production.

Great, right? Not always. The problems come in later. When these hybrid breeds are bred back to another in the flock or from another flock the characteristics do not breed true. The entire genetic makeup of the hybrid can yield undesirable traits, too. The genetic material is further watered down by further breeding. A knowledgeable breeder would take this into consideration. Introducing new breeding stock to strengthen the hybrid breed brings new vigor to the cross.

A week-by-week guide to a happy, healthy flock!

Our friends from Purina® wrote this free guide to help you enjoy your first year with chickens.  YES! I want this Free Report »

In addition to not breeding true, the hybrid breeds are weaker in the areas of longevity, and resistance to disease. Traits that are inherent in a heritage breed are not reliably passed on when making hybrid chickens. The super egg laying hens often start off well. They grow fast, begin egg laying early and all seems great. My experience with hybrids has shown that they rarely live much past a few early years of production, compared to their heritage breed flock members.

Raising Heritage Chicken Breeds

Heritage chicken breeds naturally reproduce true to the breed standards. Buying egg layer breeding stock from a certified breeder further ensures that you will have the desired breed characteristics. With heritage chicken breeds each breed has specific qualities. Feather size and colors, egg shell color, and comb and wattle size and shape are breed specific traits.


The History of Heritage Breeds in Rural Life

Many heritage breeds were kept on small farms, because of their dual-purpose of meat and egg production. Dual- purpose heritage breed chickens are hardy and adaptable to foraging situations. As family farms decreased in our country, many chicken breeds began to die out.

Dual-purpose heritage chicken breeds had little purpose in a confined agriculture egg production facility. These hens required too much food to make keeping them in a confined space profitable. Lighter commercial chicken breeds were favored by the intensive confined agricultural model. Hybrid chicken breeds were the answer. They had higher egg production and faster growth, on less feed. The downside of this form of poultry production is a lack of vigor, weather tolerance and lower ability or instinct to forage for food.

heritage chicken breeds

Another concern arises when looking into industrial hatchery breeding practices. The use of flock mating instead of specific selection based on breed qualities further weakens the gene pool. It is important to keep the gene pool fresh with additional, high-quality roosters. Not all poultry breeders adhere to this practice.

The Livestock Conservancy

Many of the heritage chicken breeds are in danger of disappearing. The Livestock Conservancy follows the requirements for breed standards. Small hatcheries are finding success and improvement following the breeding methods used by The Livestock Conservancy.

Some breed conservationists believe that we should concentrate our flocks to one or two separate groups of heritage chickens. We would commit to the improvement of the breed as we take care of the needs of our homesteads. Homesteaders who raise heritage chicken breeds are able to self-sustain a hardy dual-purpose flock. The addition of a new rooster occasionally helps to strengthen the flock’s breed characteristics.

Hybrid & Heritage Chickens

What to Consider When Breeding Heritage Chickens

First, choose your heritage chicken breed or breeds. Make your choice based on your egg or meat requirements, along with the appearance of the breed. Carefully map out how the breeding pairs will be set up. Take care to choose from different bloodlines. Add unrelated roosters to your flock occasionally, to keep the bloodlines diverse. The Livestock Conservancy notes that this can be a challenge when a breed reaches the critical status. The recommendation at that point is to concentrate on increasing breed population. Once the population increases, then focus on the breed standards.


Blue Andalusian hen.

The Livestock Conservancy has breeds of heritage chickens on a watchlist. It lists the following heritage breeds as critical: Campine, Crevecoeur, Holland, La Fleche, Malay, Modern Game, Nankin, Redcap, Spanish, Sultan, Yokohama. In addition, the Lakenvelder, Old English Game, Icelandic, and Favorelle are on the Threatened listing.

The Sussex breed is currently on the Recovering list. Lately, it has gained popularity among backyard chicken keepers, particularly the eye-catching Speckled Sussex. The Sussex is an ancient breed. In the early 1900s, the Sussex chickens were close to extinct. A few breeders committed to bringing the breed standards back and currently, the breed is recovering. Sussex hens are excellent for supplying eggs. They are considered an excellent breed for meat.


Speckled Sussex hen.

It may surprise you to read that the Barred Plymouth Rock is also on the recovering list. Plymouth Rocks were developed in America in the early 1800s. At one point they almost dropped from existence. This is an excellent farm chicken that lays an average of 200 large brown eggs per year. Rocks are cold hardy, and large. Their size makes them a good meat bird.

The Black Australorp traces its roots back to the Black Orpingtons shipped to Australian chicken breeders in the 1800’s. While the Orpington was being developed to largely provide meat, at that time, the Australian poultry breeders concentrated on the high egg production. The Australorp lays a large brown egg. Surprisingly, as the breed developed, the Black Australorp did not retain the same look as the Orpington.

Watch list entries include the Jersey Giant breed, among the largest purebred chickens. Another wonderful dual- purpose breed, although it does take up to nine months to reach full size. Andalusians are also on the watch list. The Andalusians are great foraging chickens of presumed Spanish descent. The breed lays a large white egg.


Jersey Giant hen.

The traditional Rhode Island Red has an interesting story. This superb egg laying breed also had an endangered period. The breed has shown a decline in the older, darker, original type. Commercial breeders bred them to be smaller and more efficient at egg production. This is a long way from the original standard. The breed developers originally wanted a meat bird that laid a lot of eggs.

Other heritage chicken breeds for you to consider include the Java, Sebright, Delaware, Dominiques, and Dorkings. The Brahma and Cochin breeds are two favorite large breeds. They both seem to be making a comeback in popularity.


Light Brahma hen.

Any chicken worth its weight, will eat bugs, forage for tasty greens and lay eggs. Both heritage chicken breeds and hybrid breeds will produce meat, too. The question is which breeds will do the tasks better, stay healthier while being reliable and sustainable. You can always stick with proven winners such as Leghorns, Rhode Island Reds, and Orpingtons. Those are some of the most commonly raised chickens for backyards. Choosing flock birds or breeding stock from a small certified heritage breeder helps ensure the future of the breed.

Ask yourself what your main goals are in raising chickens. If the traits are found in heritage chicken breeds, consider those birds as you start your backyard flock.

Do you have heritage chicken breeds in your flock? What are your favorites? Let us know in the comments below.

  • I started with Rode Island Reds and I failed them. But today, I still have one of the Rode Island Reds, 1 x-link Rode Island (red and white mix), 2 Buffies, 1 Plymouth Rock Barred, and 1 Arucana. They are pets and I enjoy the eggs. We are in an area that cannot have roosters. – But I love my girls. Our coop is too small to have more, but we are thinking about enlarging. I will keep in mind the heritage.

  • I love my Plymouth Barred Rocks. Besides all the qualities noted, they are friendly, docile and easy keepers.

  • You forgot Buckeyes and their interesting story. Plese support the breeds who advertise in your “Breeder’s Directory”.

  • We have a mixed flock but started concentrating on Partridge Chanteclers. Our Flock is growing and we need to get our hen count up to start our refinement to the Standard of Perfection. 1 Rooster, 4 hens, 2 cockerels not related to the rooster and hens and 2 hatchings from the Rooster and hens for 14 more young Chanteclers. We only know of 2 others in Atlantic Canada with Partridge Chanteclers.

  • Kathy W.

    My favorite chicks i have raised so far is
    Isa brown. I raised 3 hen isa brown chicks and one heritage breed lakenvelder which turned out to be a VERY aggressive rooster! So much for hand raising him in my homemade brooder in house for 2mths. I had to rehome him because he would wait for me to jump n attack me even though i hand raised him!! But the isa browns are tame and friendly and the best breed by far!! Very large hens and they are only 4 mths old! Cant wait for them to lay!
    I never heard of isa browns until i went to tractor supply and found them.
    Give this breed a try! You wont be disappointed!

    • Isa Browns are not a breed. They are a red sexlink cross. That said they are a nice chicken for brown egg production.

  • Kathleen D.

    I love my girls and I have quite the diverse flock that are open range; a pair of Buff Orpingtons, a pair of Red Orpington (they lay jumbo dark brown eggs daily), 4 Austrolorps, 2 Bared Rocks, 4 Wyndotts (2 Silver laced and 2 golden laced), 4 Ameraucana’s (Silver, Blue Wheaton and Red Brown) 16 girls in all and 1 Ruean Duck named Olivia 🙂

  • Thanks for the info. Although, a hybrid is not a breed. There is no such thing as a “hybrid breed.” A hybrid is a cross between breeds, so it’s either a hybrid OR a breed.

  • I’ve raised quite a few different breeds of chickens. Currently, my flock is all Buff Orpingtons. They are big, tame, and lay big brown eggs with orange yolks and firm egg whites. I also like Barred Rocks and any of the big Red breeds are good. I don’t like Leghorns or other Mediterranean breeds. They are flighty and hard to catch, and while they lay lots of eggs their white eggs tend to be small, with yellow yolks and watery whites. Try several different breeds for a few years then settle on the breed you like best.

  • I have a very mixed flock of both cross-breeds and heritage breeds. I have red and golden sexlinks, amberlinks, RIR crosses (given to me), and a Amberlink/black Australorp cross rooster. I have a Cochin and a Showgirl bantam that are both 4 years old, they are my oldest. My heritage breeds include a buff brahma hen, a buff Orpington rooster, 2 Columbian Wyandottes, multiple RIR hens, 2 RIR roosters, a black Australorp rooster, a Cuckoo Maran rooster (Rural King said he was a barred rock pullet), several black Australorp hens, a silver-laced Wyandotte hen and I’m drawing a blank on a few others. I just got several chicks which include silver-laced Wyandottes (3), golden-laced Wyandottes (3), Ameraucanas (2), Cuckoo Marans (3) and Jersey Giants (2) but I’m getting 4-6 Ameraucanas and 2 Barred Rocks come April 1st. I also have khaki Campbell ducks, a drake and 2 hens.

    Of all my chickens, my red sexlinks and now my amberinks tend to pick on my other chickens, including the roosters more than my roosters pick on each other. It seems the older they get, the more they pick. It’s just not over a nest or food but they will just walk up to say a Wyandotte and peck at her head for no known reason. I promised myself that I would never get any more crossed breeds again. I’m only getting heritage breeds and I’m not hatching any more eggs that I know or suspect are crossed bred.


Leave a Reply

Credit Card Identification Number

This number is recorded as an additional security precaution.


American Express

4 digit, non-embossed number printed above your account number on the front of your card.


3-digit, non-embossed number printed on the signature panel on the of the card immediately following the card account number.


3-digit, non-embossed number printed on the signature panel on the back of the card.

Enter Your Log In Credentials
This setting should only be used on your home or work computer.


Send this to a friend

Shared with you:

Does it Matter if You Raise Heritage Chicken Breeds or Hybrids?